Skip to main content
This article describes the different types of key management models, with either Multi-Party Computation (MPC) or Passkeys, so you can choose which approach to use for your development. Each wallet type has specific requirements and provides specific benefits. Use the information in this topic to choose the wallet type that best supports your business objectives.
TypeWho Controls Use of Private KeySupported Wallet typesExample Use-cases
Developer-controlledDeveloper, secured using MPC• Developer-controlled (EOA or SCA)Backend wallets that you create either for end-user or your own business’s use-case that you completely control, such as:
• Receive payment deposits and reconciliation
• Programmatic distribution of tokens, one-to-many payouts
• Programmatic interaction with dApps
• AI agent wallets
User-controlledEnd-user, secured using MPC• User-controlled (EOA or SCA)Non-custodial embedded wallets in your app. End user authentication via social login or email. Users can collect NFTs and tokens, and have full control over transactions and signing from their wallets.
PasskeysEnd-user, secured on user’s deviceModular walletsNon-custodial embedded wallets that are secured on your users’ devices. End user authentication via passkey, with ability to backup passkey to personal cloud. Users can collect NFTs and tokens, and have full control over transactions and signing from their wallets.

​
Developer-controlled wallets

Developer-controlled wallets allow developers to retain control over their own wallets, or their users’ while streamlining user interactions with the Web3 ecosystem. With developer-controlled wallets, developers can programmatically transact on behalf of their users without the need to manually sign or manage private keys. To start building developer-controlled wallets, see Create Your First Developer-Controlled Wallet. For security setup, we use 2-of-2 multi-party computation (MPC) where developers have the choice of hosting one or two of the MPC nodes, or relying on Circle to host and protect them through cryptography to ensure that developers have full control over these wallets. The options include:
  • Rely on Circle to host the 2 MPC nodes (default): The signing is protected cryptographically by an Entity Secret that you create and store on your server, and is used for every wallet creation and transaction. This option is ideal for getting started quickly with minimum setup effort.
  • Rely on Circle to host 1 of the 2 MPC nodes. Shared key management where you and Circle each host one of the MPC nodes. Circle offers a keyguard service that you host on your servers to authorize the MPC signing before every transaction. This splits the management of private keys to two parties across different servers.
  • Host both of the MPC nodes: similar to the setting above, but you host both of the MPC nodes with the keyguard service that authorizes the signing for every transaction. Such setup might be required in certain regulatory jurisdictions.
Contact Circle if you would like to host 1 or 2 of the MPC nodes yourself.

​
User-controlled wallets

User-controlled wallets grant your users full autonomy to control their assets. We use a 2-of-2 MPC setup where the MPC nodes are hosted by Circle. We leverage Shamir’s secret sharing to ensure you, your end users, and Circle, each have a key shard that is needed to access the MPC signing performed on Circle’s servers. This ensures that only end users can perform the signing after they authenticate with a familiar UX like social login, email + OTP, or PIN. To start building user-controlled wallets, see Quickstarts for Social Logins or Email Authentication.

​
Passkeys

Modular wallets can use passkeys as signers. Passkeys are secured on the user device’s secure enclave, ensuring end users have full autonomy over signing and transacting with their wallet. This setup ensures that end users authorize all signing activities, while providing a familiar and seamless Web2-like user experience. To start building passkey authenticated modular wallets, see Create Your First Passkey Authenticated Modular Wallet.

​
Backing up your keys for recovery

To reassure that you and your users have access to your wallets at all times, Circle provides ways to backup your keys or your end users’ keys for operational continuity. For developer-controlled wallets, Circle offers a key backup and recovery tool that allows you to backup your keys and perform signing. Contact Circle if you have this need. For modular wallets with Passkey signing by your end users, you can leverage the FIDO2 backup standard supported by iCloud, Google Drive, and password managers like 1Password to let your end users backup their passkeys in a secure way that only they have access to.

​
Choosing your key management type

The critical distinction between user-controlled, developer-controlled, and passkey wallets is which party controls the ability to access the private key used to interact with the blockchain. In the case of user-controlled or passkey wallets, the user controls this ability. In the case of developer-controlled wallets, the developer has this control. All types of wallets can make transactions, interact with smart contracts, and sign messages.
⌘I